Amore Pizzeria And Fine Foods

The Food You Love To Eat

Long Island's Premier
Pizzeria and Catering Company

Amore Dishes

For family get-togethers, cozy nights at home, big games, working lunches, teen sleepovers, or just plain old tough days, you can’t beat fast, fresh, and fantastic Italian food.

Daily Menu has an amazing selection of delicious dishes to satisfy everyone around the table.

No need to cook tonight Mama! Pick up the phone to Amore and we’ll deliver right to your door.
Daily Menu

Something Different

Amore has something different and special every day of the week. Fresh cooked to our family’s traditional Italian recipes, all our specials come with a side order of salad and garlic bread. And at Amore prices, you don’t need to wait for a big occasion to treat yourself.

Check out Mike and Richie’s Italian Daily Specials today. And if you want something different tomorrow – well, come back and try another!
Daily Specials 

Amore Pizzeria & Fine Foods
Delivered to your door: 631-968-8181

Bayshore, Islip, East Islip and The Surrounding Areas

Catering For All Occasions

When you’ve got a crowd to cater for, Amore Pizzeria has you covered. We’ve been feeding parties of hungry Long Islanders at every kind of occasion for nearly 30 years. Choose from our tasty range of Cold platters, Hot Food Trays, and Party Hero pizzas sold by the foot!

Then relax and spend time with your guests. We can manage all the covers you need and organize everything you need to keep them all happy and coming back for more.
Amore Catering

The Founders

Amore Pizza was established January 1st 1991. The owners are Richie and Mike. Amore has been very dedicated in serving the community for over 28 years. They have served many charitable events, have donated their services to many organizations and have served the pharmaceutical industry for over 24 years.

Amore Pizzeria and Fine Foods is known for their short notice catering for all occasions. As for our catering we are known to serve good quality service to local business and homeowners.
Dee Love
July 30, 2021

Every time I come home to New York from Colorado I make this one of my stops been eating here for ever Love the food.

Lisa DeCola
December 31, 2020

You can keep all your other pizza places! This place, hands down has ALWAYS had the best in the area!

James Cunningham
May 4, 2020

I'm a lasagna lover and I love Amore's lasagna. Love their 🍕 pizzas as well.

Grace Klein
April 6, 2020

I want to give a HUGE SHOUT OUT to Amore’s Pizza in Bay Shore for their generous donation today! They delivered fresh hot pizza for 3 shifts worth of essential staff at Maria Regina Residence in Brentwood. During this horrific time we face, while many restaurants are struggling to stay open, they selflessly donated their time and energy to feed our staff. My hope is that when things get back to normal (or even before that) the community supports the same restaurants such as Amore’s when choosing where to pick up lunch or dinner. I will always order from Amores not just because they have the best pizza around, but because they did such a selfless deed for our hard working staff.

Vicky Studioso Douglass
April 4, 2020

Thank you so much for the donation of food to Southside cardiology. It was delicious and so appreciated. You guys are the best!!

Angel Jimenez
August 23, 2019

Some of the best pizza I have ever had.

Walter William Molina
June 27, 2019

5/5. I enjoy Amore pizza everytime I order.

Kim Morrison-Gannon
June 11, 2019

Amore pizza donated food for my fundraiser this past weekend. My guests raved about the food and Richie was so helpful and generous. Thank you amore for all you do for this community!

Heather Doherty
April 19, 2019

Love the food and the owners a great community people supporting everything from girls scouts , Lions Club, and thé schools.... always a pleasure to visit and always friendly on the phone delivery service

Hanora Kahler
February 20, 2019

Great food and great staff

Shannon Rose Bartels
May 31, 2018

Great Place! Love eating here both takeout and dining in

Jeff Cohen
April 21, 2018

Food is amazing!! Great atmosphere and service is great!!!!

Lisa Reilly
March 23, 2018

My family and I have dined here on several occasions with no complaints. Experienced nothing but the best service on every visit from the owner and staff. The food is authentic and taste delicious. There is an assortment of food choices and the selections are reasonably priced.

Christa Riccaldo Ramos
February 19, 2018

Best pizza around says my son who’s tried pizza everywhere

Eric Schwarz
June 4, 2017

Great service, good people ,and great pizza shop. I will return to amore pizzeria

Marie Lehron-Carman
May 24, 2017

Best Italian anywhere. Known these guys for more than 25 yrs and no one does it better. Great food, greater people!!

Linda I Grant
March 13, 2017

Thee ABSOLUTELY BEST Pizza and Italian food ever**

Bill Rb
March 11, 2017

Always great food and great service from a place that also supports the community. Thank you!

Jamie Louise
January 13, 2017

Love Amore Pizzeria!!! They catered a couple of parties for me!!! Food was delicious and my family raved about it!! We especially love their alla vodka sauce!!! Sooooooo good!!

Colleen Varley
December 17, 2016

Thank you Amore Pizza for your support of our school! Your food for our Shine and Dine with Santa event was amazing! You are such a pleasure to work with!


2110 Union Blvd
Bay Shore NY 11706
Get Directions

Hours Of Operation

Monday - Thursday 11:00 am - 10:00 pm
Friday - Saturday 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Sunday 12:00 am - 9:00 pm
© 2023 Amore Pizzeria and Fine Foods
Website Designed By Odd Ball Media Group